Skip to content
HarborSource UK

A United Ireland Plebiscite Must Not Transform Into 'Another Brexit', Experts Alert

Ten years after the UK stumbled into a rushed public vote that split the country and caused turmoil, a warning is issued from beyond the Irish Sea: it could happen again.

Authorities and citizens sleepwalked into Brexit and the identical might transpire with a national vote on a united Ireland, triggering convulsions for which nobody is prepared.

That conveys the caution from two prominent writers from each side of the Irish border who have collaborated to scrutinise the benefits and drawbacks of Northern Ireland exiting the UK to establish a new state with the Republic of Ireland.

Political Establishments Unprepared

Fintan O’Toole and Sam McBride, have determined that the government bodies in Ireland and Britain are extremely unready for a potentially contentious and transformative public vote.

"The crucial insight of Brexit hasn't been learned, which is that events can arise suddenly and can gather momentum very quickly," O’Toole said. "It is my view that the institutional structure of our archipelago remains very unstable."

Released Volume Seeks to Provoke Discussion

The duo have studied the governmental, financial and cultural rationales for any governmental shift in a publication, For and Against a United Ireland, released by the Dublin-based Royal Irish Academy.

They seek to stir debate on the issue with a series of public talks that will take them to Westminster soon.

"What troubles all parties, or should haunt every person, is the Brexit vote of 2016," stated O’Toole.

"We do not want a referendum on a binary, vague proposition whose consequences have remained undefined because then you land with an extraordinarily split population where people who have lost are resistant to defeat and the victorious side lack clarity precisely what it is that they have gained."

Legal Framework

Under the peace accord, the Northern Ireland government minister is obliged to schedule a public vote on Irish unification if it seems probable that a majority would vote in favour.

Sinn Féin and other nationalists claim this point is looming, and a non-profit called pro-unification advocates has built momentum, but authorities in Dublin and London and pro-UK factions play down the likelihood, making it uncertain whether or when there could be a national vote.

Absence of Serious Debate

Ideological statements supporting and opposing unity has hidden the absence of informed dialogue, said McBride.

"Individuals are often supportive or opposed the idea but the concrete planning which might go beyond that to achieve it has largely not occurred. A great deal has taken place in academia but hardly any elected officials or campaigners are willing to participate even with the essentials. As an example, which kind of country should be desired? Unitary? Federal?"

Volume's Strategy

In the volume, none of the commentators supports unity or the existing arrangement. Both writes two articles that seek impartiality in detailing the case for a unified Ireland and the argument opposing it, gathering financial and societal data, historical precedents and structural examples.

Debates range over identity markers, taxes, medical care, retirement funds, national debt responsibilities and the danger of pro-UK militancy. The aim is to educate and provoke discussion.

"Considerable attention exists in the issue but there hasn't quite been a debate," said O’Toole. "Debate implies an acceptance of the notion that there may exist good arguments on both sides."

Dual Referendums

A referendum in Northern Ireland would also trigger one in the republic, where citizens say they support unification but oppose greater financial contributions or adopting a alternative symbol to reflect unionists' British culture.

"Authorities in Dublin must work out what the proposal from pro-unification movements is beyond just saying: 'We seek a unified Ireland and we welcome you'," stated the commentator.

Likelihood of Public Vote

The journalist considers a referendum in his era is possible and that it might occur abruptly. "There might be just a irresponsible or a poor or a incompetent government minister who states: 'Let us proceed and resolve it.'"

Both pro-unification advocates and pro-UK supporters have credible, valid perspectives, he said. "One side will prevail on this issue and the other side will in the end lose but all factions has got valuable insights to gain from the other's viewpoints."

Call for Wider Dialogue

Westminster should participate in the debate, urged O’Toole. "This is about Britain. It is a British question just as much as it is an Irish question."

MG
Written by

Mark Green

Eleanor is a maritime journalist with 15 years of experience covering global shipping and port operations.

HarborSource UK

Type to search articles.